Highland Park Methodist Church logo

ECCLESIASTICAL RESOLUTION OF THE CHURCH COUNCIL

October 13, 2026

Whereas for the past 110 years, a Methodist Church (the “Church”) at the corner of Mockingbird Lane and Hillcrest Avenue in Dallas, Texas has served the members of the congregation and the city of Dallas faithfully; and

Whereas, the Church has faithfully maintained its identity and core as a place of worship informed by and deeply rooted in the Wesleyan Methodist theological tradition; and

Whereas, the Church has, from time to time, taken steps to assure its ability to govern itself in accordance with governance practices that best serve the congregation, while maintaining its adherence to Wesleyan Methodist theological tradition; and

Whereas, in 1998, as a result of membership growth and the attendant complexities that attach to large churches, and recognizing the necessity of streamlining that governance, the Church, acting through its charge conference and with the express participation and approval of the Conference, authorized the incorporation of Highland Park United Methodist Church, as a Texas not-for-profit corporation, and authorized the adoption of bylaws for the governance of the Highland Park United Methodist Church; and

Whereas, in 2022, as a result of changes in Texas law, the Church restated its articles of incorporation, becoming Highland Park Methodist Church, doing business as Highland Park United Methodist Church, and amended its bylaws to conform with the latest statements of Texas state law regarding the governance of religious not-for-profit corporations, all in accordance with neutral principles of Texas law and the amendment provisions of its corporate documents then in effect; and

Whereas, on January 3, 2023, the Church informed the North Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church of the changes in its name and provided the North Texas Conference as-filed copies of both the assumed name certificate and the restated certificate of formation, which contained a detailed description of the amendments, plus the full text of the restated articles of incorporation, and asked the North Texas Conference to share that information with its parent body, the General Council on Finance and Administration of the United Methodist Church (the “UMC”); and

Whereas, the North Texas Conference acknowledged receipt and shared the foregoing documents with the UMC, which confirmed receipt on January 6, 2023, and which was followed by the UMC confirming the Church’s continuing status within the UMC and its tax exemption under the Church’s new name and articles on January 20, 2023; and

Whereas, from January 1, 1999, until October 21, 2025, a period of more than 26 years, various bishops of the UMC charged with overseeing the North Texas Conference, and its successor the Horizon Texas Conference of the United Methodist Church (together, the “Conference”) have recognized and respected the Church’s rights; and

Whereas, on October 21, 2025, the Conference, through its bishop, claimed to have newly become aware of the 2022 changes; and

Whereas, the bishop took the new position that the lawfully adopted amendments must be rescinded on ecclesiastical grounds, a position without lawful basis and and with which the Church Council respectfully disagrees; and

Whereas, the Church has at all times acted in full ecclesiastical connection with, in complete loyalty to, and in full cooperation with the Conference in all of its conduct under its self-governance for 26 years; and

Whereas, despite those facts, the bishop of the Conference determined that he would not accept the Church continuing to operate under its current governance; and

Whereas, on July 21, 2026, the bishop caused a Formal Written Complaint to be filed against the senior minister of the Church, which could result in the loss of the senior minister’s ministerial credentials with the UMC; and

Whereas, on August 10, 2026, the Conference filed a lawsuit against Highland Park Methodist Church doing business as Highland Park United Methodist Church in the state courts of Texas, asserting that the 2022 amendments violated ecclesiastical law; and

Whereas, the Conference has communicated publicly and directly with members of the Church regarding the dispute, including by letter dated September 18, 2026; and

Whereas, all of these acts have taken place in written and spoken communications made available either through the lawsuit, public relations statements, letters, and videos, which, in the view of the Church Council, have sought to weaken the foundations of the properly and legally chosen lay leadership of the Church; and

Whereas, the Church Council believes that these actions have broken the bond of trust that once existed between the Church and the UMC; and

Whereas, the Church Council believes that the governance rights and procedures the Church has maintained since 1998, as amended in 2022 and 2024 under Texas law, remain in the best interests of the Church as a legal matter, and as an ecclesiastical matter have for years, with the Conference’s awareness and respect, permitted the Church to most effectively maintain its ministry and mission and serve its clergy and membership; and

Whereas, the parties’ discussions since October 2025 have not produced a resolution that would allow the Church to continue as it has for 26 years, with a right of self-governance and maintaining a meaningful voice in the selection and retention of clergy serving its membership, as it has since 1999 in full view of the Conference and with its collaboration and partnership until now; and

Whereas, it is incumbent upon the Church Council to lead and to provide its best counsel, through prayer, discernment and love of this historic Church; to defend the congregation; to protect our clergy whose livelihoods are currently being threatened; and to inform the congregation of these events and acts toward the Church; and

Whereas, having reached this impasse, facing an uninvited lawsuit, living with the breach of trust caused by the Conference and its bishop, and being unwilling to forfeit the Church’s longstanding self-governance, the Church Council has reached the conclusion that the time is right to recommend that the Church sever all affiliation with the UMC while preserving the historic ministry and mission of the Church and continuing the Church’s faithful adherence to Wesleyan Methodist theological tradition; and

Whereas, the Church Council has previously today adopted amended and restated bylaws of the Church (the “Church’s Bylaws”), which among other things provides that any decision to join, or affiliate or connect with, any religious organization, order, denomination or group of churches, or amending or terminating any such joining, affiliation, or connection, shall be required to be put to a vote of the Professing Members of the Church (as defined in the Church’s Bylaws) who are registered on the Church’s rolls;

Now therefore, be it resolved that, pursuant to the Church’s Bylaws, the Church Council hereby calls for a Church-Wide Vote (as defined in the Church’s Bylaws) of the Professing Members of the Church who are registered as Professing Members of the Church on the Church’s rolls as of October 25, 2026, to be held on October 25 and October 26, 2026 at the Church’s Mockingbird campus, by the methods prescribed in the Church’s Bylaws, to answer “Yes” or “No” on this question (the “Question”): “Shall Highland Park Methodist Church, doing business as Highland Park United Methodist Church, sever all of its ties, affiliations, and connections to The United Methodist Church?” and

Be it further resolved, that for all of the reasons described above, the Church Council recommends a “Yes” vote on the Question; and

Be it further resolved, that the staff of the Church, under the direction and supervision of the Chairperson of the Church Council, are authorized and directed to implement the time, place and manner for the Church-Wide Vote, consistent with this Resolution and the Church’s Bylaws; and

Be it further resolved, that the Church Council will act in accordance with the results of the Church-Wide Vote; and

Be it further resolved, that the Church Council shall so inform the bishop and the Conference of the outcome of the Church-Wide Vote; and

Be it further resolved, that regardless of the outcome of the Church-Wide Vote, the Church will remain a Methodist Church deeply rooted in and adhering to the Wesleyan Methodist theological tradition as it fulfills its ministry and mission to help people become deeply devoted followers of Christ; and

Be it further resolved, that regardless of the outcome of the Church-Wide Vote, the Church Council affirms its commitment to the care, support, and protection of the Church’s clergy and staff; and

Be it further resolved, that this ecclesiastical and religious Resolution and its directives, including the congregation’s discernment and the Church-Wide Vote, are separate from, and without prejudice to, the civil questions before the court on corporate amendment procedure in 2022 or 2024, which can and will be resolved solely under neutral principles of civil law, as Texas courts require.