News & Conference Updates
An Important Update from HPMC Lay Leaders
November 13, 2026
Dear HPMC Church Family,
In recent weeks, the Horizon Texas Conference has taken several actions affecting our Church. We believe you deserve an accurate understanding of developments involving the Conference following our vote, and we want to share them with you.
While these actions do not have any legal effect on HPMC's governance or leadership, they have created significant confusion and concern. These actions include:
Claiming to remove Matt and Paul from their appointments with us.
Demanding Matt provide Rev. Andy Lewis with “keys” and materials as part of what the Bishop describes as a transition of senior leadership (fortunately, they have backed down from that demand).
Declared all members of our elected Church Council disqualified from serving and claimed that the Council's October 26 letter regarding HPMC’s vote was a withdrawal from church membership.
Established a separate congregation using our longstanding and legally protected name, colors, font, and other identifiers, launching a near identical website to ours and fundraising from our members under our legal identity for their new entity.
These actions have had real consequences. In the days that followed, our Church received more than 100 calls from people seeking clarification. Some expressed concern about whether their contributions were going to the right church, and others asked about canceling recurring gifts out of concern that their donations might be redirected.
These developments contrast with the Conference’s earlier assurances that their concerns were solely about governance and the voice of our congregation. Our congregation has spoken through an overwhelming vote, and that decision deserves to be respected.
At the same time, we respect the right of those who wish to remain United Methodist to establish a separate congregation and sincerely wish them well. Our concern is not with the establishment of another congregation by the UMC, but with the Conference's efforts to confuse or disrupt the community, our members, and the staff of our Church, who are spending countless hours dealing with the Conference’s public relations maneuvers and threats.
Lawsuit Updates
We have a responsibility to faithfully steward the faith, identity, community, and resources that generations have entrusted to us.
In fulfilling that responsibility, upon the advice of our legal team, HPMC issued two cease-and-desist letters addressing the use of our Church's registered name and trademarks in connection with the newly formed congregation's fundraising activities solicited through their near identical website.
Accordingly, HPMC also filed a Texas Rule 91a Motion to Dismiss, an Application for a Temporary Restraining Order (related to trademarks), and a First Amended Answer containing Affirmative Defenses and Counterclaims.
These legal steps are not about conflict or about preventing anyone from worshiping or establishing a United Methodist congregation. Indeed, as we have said, we will transition away from use of “United,” returning to our earlier historic name carved over our sanctuary. We welcome the Conference’s new congregation to choose from any of the nearly infinite names that use “United Methodist Church” but do not cause confusion and discord by appropriating our legally protected corporate name, trademarks, legal identity, and goodwill.
It is important to remember that the Conference initiated this lawsuit long before any vote, and we welcome them to stop and coexist peacefully as neighbors. The law we quoted to the court today shows that under neutral principles of law, the threat of confusion and misappropriation is heightened when a historic entity transitions its name and a new entity attempts to confuse the community by trading on that historic legal name and identity. Our actions are about protecting our Church, preserving our legal continuity and goodwill, and ensuring that the ministries and mission of HPMC can continue without disruption. As stewards of this Church and its legacy, we have a responsibility to protect what generations before us have built and what we are called to carry forward.
Looking Ahead
Through all of this, what continues to stand out most is this congregation's extraordinary faith, generosity, and commitment. Our calling to help people become deeply devoted followers of Jesus Christ has not changed. Our ministries continue, and the opportunities before us are tremendous.
Thank you for your prayers, generosity, and unwavering commitment to Highland Park Methodist Church. We are grateful for this congregation and confident in the future God is calling us to build together.
Our best days are ahead.
With gratitude and faith,
Caroline Nowlin
Chair, Church Council
Mark Freeman
Chair, Pastoral Relations Committee
Previous Statements & Resolutions
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Why did the conference file a lawsuit? (Updated 9.4.26)
We can’t speak for the conference or the bishop, and we also won't speculate. The lawsuit complains about our bylaw amendments, but the allegations are simply without merit. Everything we did was in line with the latest Texas law, the best interests of our Church, and the governing documents approved by the conference and bishop from the start.
While every situation is different, HPUMC is far from the only local church to have faced legal action involving the United Methodist Church or an annual conference. Since the suit was filed, we have become aware of many other lawsuits between the UMC and other local churches.
Where does the lawsuit stand? (Added 10.12.26)
You can read our answer to the conference’s lawsuit here. The lawsuit is an active legal matter, and there are limits to what church leaders can discuss publicly while the process is ongoing. We want to provide the congregation with as much clarity as we can while respecting those limits. We will continue to share information through official HPUMC communications channels as appropriate.
Why isn't mediation an option? (Added 10.20.26)
We understand why many members have asked about mediation with the conference. It is a fair question, and one we take seriously. It is important to remember that it is the conference and bishop that sued us, and they have not offered mediation. In fact, the bishop recently amended the lawsuit to seek monetary damages from our Church. We are baffled by this escalation, because the only money that has changed hands since 2022 is the nearly $12 million dollars we paid to the conference and other Methodist organizations, after they received our corporate changes and approved our continued membership under their tax exemption.
Beyond the lawsuit, the bishop has threatened our clergy’s appointments, pensions, and health care and has demanded the replacement of our duly elected lay leadership. While he talks about reconciliation, he has consistently said the only way to get there is to fully submit to his demands. When we face the reality we are in, we do not see a partner for peace and collaboration. We have to look forward and chart our own future.
Who is eligible to participate in the church-wide vote? (Added 10.20.26)
To vote, an individual must be a Professing Member of Highland Park United Methodist Church (HPUMC) who is registered as a Professing Member on HPUMC’s rolls as of October 25, 2026.
Simply attending worship, participating in youth ministry, or attending Confirmation classes does not, on its own, establish professing membership. Only individuals who have completed the applicable membership process and are recognized as professing members of HPUMC are eligible to vote.
Professing membership may be established through one of the following pathways:
Adults: Profess faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, receive Christian baptism, take the membership vows (commit to the life of the Church through prayers, presence, gifts, service, and witness), and complete the membership form.
Kids and Youth: Complete HPUMC’s Confirmation program, personally affirm their Christian faith and commitment to follow Jesus Christ, and participate in the Rite of Confirmation, during which they publicly profess their faith and make the confirmation and membership vows. Kids & Youth (regardless of age) who have not been baptized, received the Rite of Confirmation, and professed their faith are not eligible to vote.
For eligibility questions, please email inquiry@hpmc.org. To verify your membership status, please text "member" to 469-436-5590.
Are kids and youth eligible to vote? (Added 10.23.26)
To vote, an individual must be a Professing Member of Highland Park United Methodist Church (HPUMC) who is registered as a Professing Member on HPUMC’s rolls as of October 25, 2026.
Kids and youth are eligible to vote if they are HPUMC members who have been baptized, completed Confirmation, and professed their faith.
Simply attending worship, participating in youth ministry, or attending Confirmation classes does not, on its own, establish professing membership. Only individuals who have completed the applicable membership process and are recognized as professing members of HPUMC are eligible to vote.
Professing membership for kids and youth may be established through the following pathway:
Kids and Youth: Complete HPUMC’s Confirmation program, personally affirm their Christian faith and commitment to follow Jesus Christ, and participate in the Rite of Confirmation, during which they publicly profess their faith and make the confirmation and membership vows. Kids & Youth (regardless of age) who have not been baptized, received the Rite of Confirmation, and professed their faith are not eligible to vote.
For eligibility questions, please email inquiry@hpmc.org. To verify your membership status, please text "member" to 469-436-5590.
Members under the age of 18 must also verify both their membership and their identity and may bring any of the forms of valid ID listed below, or a parent/legal guardian may present their own form of identification and can verify the minors’ name.
Driver’s license
Student ID
State-issued ID
U.S. passport
Military ID
What percentage of "Yes" votes cast is required for the resolution to pass? (Added 10.20.26)
The resolution requires a simple majority of the votes cast by eligible members voting in person on October 25–26 to be “Yes” votes in order to pass. This percentage is based on the number of eligible members who vote in person, not the total membership of the Church. Members will be voting "Yes" or "No." Members who do not participate in the vote will not be counted as voting “Yes” or “No.” Only votes cast by eligible members voting in person will be counted.
The Church Council's recommendation on a “Yes” vote reflects the Council’s determination and conviction that a “Yes” vote is the only way to preserve our longstanding right to self-governance while protecting our Church's historic ministry and mission.
Why can’t church leaders answer every question about the lawsuit? (Added 10.12.26)
The lawsuit is an active legal matter, and there are limits to what Church leaders can discuss publicly while the process is ongoing. We want to provide the congregation with as much clarity as we can while respecting those limits. We will continue to share information through official HPUMC communications channels as appropriate. In the meantime, you can review our official response to the lawsuit filed against us by the conference here.
What was the process that led to the complaint and the lawsuit? (Added 9.4.26)
In summary, the complaint against Rev. Tuggle was filed after only three meetings that took place over a five month period; the lawsuit was filed after a fourth meeting related to Rev. Tuggle’s ecclesiastical judicial process.
On July 20, the bishop’s office emailed Rev. Tuggle to notify him that a formal complaint had been filed against him. This was the first time the bishop reached out to Rev. Tuggle since December 2025. Rev. Tuggle was appointed as our senior minister on February 2, 2026—meaning the first interaction the bishop had with Rev. Tuggle as the senior minister of our Church was the notification of the complaint.
Further, the last interaction anyone from the conference had with anyone from HPUMC related to the bylaws was in early March. Our focus through the spring and summer was on facilitating a smooth senior minister transition and completing the first phase of our Project Mockingbird construction.
We had no indication the denomination was preparing the complaint, the lawsuit, and the proactive PR campaign. First Rev. Tuggle, and then our Church, were blindsided by the filing of the complaint and then the lawsuit.
During the entire process, HPUMC has responded to every request from the conference for conversation. A detailed account of the timeline was given at the congregation Town Hall meeting held on August 26.
Why did I hear about the Horizon Texas Conference’s lawsuit against our Church through the media? (Updated 9.4.26)
Our clergy, staff and lay leadership were caught completely off guard by the filing of this lawsuit. Because the Horizon Texas Conference chose to file a civil lawsuit without telling us, the filing became public record—allowing it to both be discovered by and reported on—before we had the chance to communicate with our congregation. We are all disappointed and bewildered by the conference’s action, especially because our leadership met with the bishop just prior to the filing. Despite this unexpected lawsuit, we remain focused on ministering to our congregation, just as we have for 110 years.
Were we aware that the bishop and the conference were planning to sue us?
Absolutely not. We met with the bishop twice recently. At no point did the bishop give any indication that his staff had been preparing for legal action for several months. In fact, we now know that when we last met face-to-face with the bishop, he had already filed the lawsuit.
Why did we change the bylaws, and what changes did we make? (Updated 9.4.26)
In 2022, HPUMC chose to remain part of our connectional family, during a period when more than 7,600 churches ultimately left the United Methodist Church. We did not want to leave our denomination, and we had no dispute with the conference. During this period, there was significant uncertainty within the denomination, including ongoing legal disputes involving UMC-related institutions such as our historic partner and neighbor, SMU. We needed to make sure that our congregation was legally protected, even as we maintained our religious and ecclesiastical connections. As changing Texas law requires, we also maintain and refresh our bylaws as necessary, and in accordance with Texas law, to keep our governance in line with best practices.
That meant making sure that our corporate bylaws and articles were in line with the latest guidance from the Texas Supreme Court. In 2020, the Texas Supreme Court made clear that courts would not accept religious terms or doctrinal rules embedded in corporate documents—churches that wished to protect their legal rights needed to make sure their corporate papers were corporate, not religious. That’s what the courts mean when they say “neutral principles” of law.
That's what we did. And as the resolution we passed at the time made clear, it was not because we wanted to leave, but because we saw the litigation and discord around us. We needed to know—if litigation or other troubles ever reached our doorstep—we had the corporate papers in place that would stand the test of time and protect our congregation's ability to thrive, no matter what happened in the future to our conference, or denomination, in 5, 10, or 50 years. We believed then, and believe now, this is reasonable.
Following the courts' guidance and removing religious and doctrinal references from our corporate legal documents changed nothing about our daily practice under and respect for the Book of Discipline or our religious affiliations. We simply followed the best advice we could from courts to keep our corporate documents corporate and enforceable under neutral principles of Texas law. And we kept our religious and ecclesiastical practices where they belong—not in corporate papers but inside our church.
In making these changes, we followed the corporate governance and procedures laid out in our original 1998/1999 corporate documents to the tee—governance explicitly blessed and adopted under the supervision of the denomination. No two churches within the denomination are exactly the same or have the same governance needs. For decades, our congregation has operated with the conference's knowledge under a lay-led Church Council model. In 1998, HPUMC’s Charge Conference, in partnership with the conference and bishop at the time, unanimously delegated authority to enact and amend the church’s bylaws to the Church Council, and bylaws adopted in 1999 and amended from time to time thereafter reflected that governance structure. This model has enabled our congregation to be governed and led effectively while maintaining its ministry and ecclesiastical beliefs.
For the past 27 years our Church has functioned under our own bylaws without complaint from, and in full cooperation with the UMC, as have many other United Methodist churches. For the past four of those years, we have done so under the 2022 amendments now in question.
On August 10, our denomination, by way of the Horizon Texas Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church, filed a lawsuit seeking a Declaratory Judgment in Dallas County District Court. But conference leadership was directly informed when we updated our corporate name in 2022. In the years since, we have been active members of the conference, never missed a monthly apportionment payment to the conference, and contributed countless hours of service and more than $12,000,000 to the conference and organizations of the United Methodist Church. The conference accepted our apportionments without complaint as recently as this August. The only thing that has changed is the current bishop’s interpretation of our governance and the conference’s position on it—but our relationship with the conference has remained open, collaborative, and aligned since 1998, until this new lawsuit.
The suit represents the denomination’s efforts to undo the rights our articles and bylaws afford to our congregation, undoing not only the 2022 amendments but also effectively erasing the corporate governance we have operated under—with the conference’s blessing—since 1999. Additionally, after meeting with HPUMC representatives on only three occasions over a five month period, in late July and early August, the Horizon Texas Annual Conference of the UMC also filed a formal complaint against our senior minister, Rev. Matt Tuggle, the first step in the denomination’s ecclesiastical judicial process.
Did the conference know we changed our corporate documents in 2022? (Updated 9.10.26)
As a matter of fact, yes. The conference leadership was directly informed when we updated our corporate documents. We promptly shared our name change with the conference and sent the conference copies of our as-filed Restated Certificate of Formation, which had both a detailed summary of the changes we made, as well as the amended articles themselves. The conference confirmed receipt, and shared the materials at our request with its central financial, legal, and administrative agency, the General Council on Finance and Administration (GCFA) of the United Methodist Church. GCFA sent us back written confirmation of our continued inclusion in UMC's tax umbrella under our updated corporate form.
These administrative updates followed standard non-profit practices, were guided by corporate counsel, and fit within the long-standing framework in which local governance is handled by our elected lay-leaders, as it always has been. Historically, we have not submitted bylaw updates to the conference because the conference has never asked or required us to do so. Local bylaw updates have not required conference approval or inclusion on the District Superintendent's annual Charge Conference agenda, which they themselves set.
What are the bishop’s objections to the changes? Did we violate the Methodist Church’s “Book of Discipline”? (Updated 9.4.26)
We can’t speak for the conference or the bishop.
Working within the articles and bylaws our Church established in 1998-1999 and under guidance issued by the Texas Supreme Court in 2020, we amended our bylaws to allow us to stay within the UMC while retaining our ability to protect our congregation and thrive in the future, no matter what happened in our conference or denomination in 5, 15, or 50 years. It is our bylaws that kept our Church in our denomination and kept our Church together. We believed then, and believe now, this is reasonable.
In 2020, the Texas courts gave important guidance on managing church affairs under neutral principles of Texas law. We revised our corporate documents accordingly. Everything the lay leadership of this Church did followed the clear procedures in our longstanding corporate documents. As stewards, we must ensure our corporate documents are legally sustainable.
For the past 27 years our Church has functioned under our own bylaws without complaint from, and in full cooperation with the UMC, as have many other United Methodist churches. For the past four of those years, we have done so under the 2022 amendments now in question. Conference leadership was directly informed when we updated our corporate name in 2022. In the years since, we have been active members of the conference, never missed a monthly apportionment payment to the conference, and contributed countless hours of service and more than $12,000,000 to the conference and organizations of the United Methodist Church. The conference accepted our apportionments without complaint as recently as this August. Far from any plan to leave the denomination, these revisions 2022 bylaws allowed us to remain in the denomination despite the discord around us. The only thing that has changed is the current bishop’s interpretation of our governance and the conference’s position on it—but our relationship with the conference has remained open, collaborative, and aligned since 1998, until this new lawsuit.
Why not simply change the documents back to the way they were before? (Updated 9.4.26)
In 2020, the Texas courts gave important guidance on managing church affairs under neutral principles of Texas law. We revised our corporate documents accordingly. Everything the lay leadership of this Church did followed the clear procedures in our longstanding corporate documents. As stewards, we must ensure our corporate documents are legally sustainable.
Our corporate documents were updated in 2022 to ensure they appropriately reflected that guidance and to protect our congregation as a legal matter, even as we maintained our religious and ecclesiastical connections.
For the past 27 years our Church has functioned under our own bylaws without complaint from, and in full cooperation with the UMC, as have many other United Methodist churches. For the past four of those years, we have done so under the 2022 amendments now in question, again without complaint from the conference. The only thing that has changed is the current bishop’s interpretation of our governance and the conference’s position on it—but our relationship with the conference has remained open, collaborative, and aligned since 1998, until this new lawsuit.
Those changes were made carefully, in good faith, and with the long-term interests and stability of our Church in mind. As stewards of our Church, we will follow Texas law and best practices.
Were we trying to distance ourselves from the United Methodist Church? (Updated 9.4.26)
By 2023, more than 7,600 churches nationwide had left the United Methodist Church. Highland Park United Methodist did not go that route. We chose to remain part of the denomination.
In 2022, we amended our bylaws in response to the guidance from the Texas Supreme Court and to ensure that our congregation was protected as a legal matter, no matter what happened in the future with our denomination or conference.
Until this unnecessary and unjust lawsuit filed by the conference, we have never considered leaving the United Methodist Church.
We will remain focused on being who we are as a Church – and that means ministering to our congregation just as we have over the past 110 years.
We continue to pray for wisdom and understanding as this matter is addressed.
Why didn’t we call a vote in 2022? (Updated 9.4.26)
In 1998 our Charge Conference, in partnership with the conference and bishop at the time, voted unanimously to delegate authority to enact and amend the Church’s bylaws to the Church Council. Those bylaws adopted in 1999 and amended from time to time thereafter reflect that governance structure. This lay-led Church Council model, which remains in place today, has enabled our congregation to be governed and led effectively while maintaining its ministry and ecclesiastical beliefs.
In 2022, while navigating a historic moment for our denomination, our senior minister at the time held meetings with lay-leaders and key stakeholders within the congregation to talk about the UMC schism and how our Church was navigating that. Additionally, HPUMC clergy hosted a series of classes entitled “Schism: What Is Happening to the UMC?” designed for anyone who wanted to take a deeper dive into the Church’s history, beliefs, and what made us distinctive. The Church continued to state our desire to stay in the denomination, but was forthright about our readiness to leave if necessary. It was then that the 2022 bylaws were amended by duly elected lay leadership, selected in exactly the same way lay leadership in every other United Methodist church is selected.
The only thing that has changed is the current bishop’s interpretation of our governance and the conference’s position regarding it—but our relationship with the conference has remained open, collaborative, and in alignment since 1998, until this new lawsuit.
Why wasn’t there more communication about the bylaw amendments made in 2022? (Added 9.4.26)
Conference leadership was directly informed when we updated our corporate name in 2022.
Historically, we have not submitted bylaw updates to the conference because the conference has never asked or required us to do so. Local bylaw updates have not required conference approval, or inclusion on the District Superintendent's annual Charge Conference agenda, which they themselves set.
We did not make a larger announcement following the bylaw amendments in 2022 because in our view, nothing had changed. The sign on our door remained the same, as did our daily and vibrant participation within the conference and denomination for years to follow.
Far from any plan to leave the denomination, these revisions to the 2022 bylaws allowed us to remain in the denomination despite the discord around us. The only thing that has changed is the current bishop’s interpretation of our governance and the conference’s position on it—but our relationship with the conference has remained open, collaborative, and aligned since 1998, until this new lawsuit.
Who owns our Church property and other campus properties? (Updated 10.20.26)
This church on Hillcrest and Mockingbird and our other properties have been our home over the past 100 years, and that will not change. We have seen the conference threaten others through legal action against their properties. They did so with SMU and were not successful. They did so again recently with another congregation in our conference and again were not successful. We are confident in our legal positions, among many other reasons because our sanctuary was fully deeded to us by SMU in 1926. Our thriving congregation of 15,000 loyal Wesleyan Methodists will always have the home and facilities we have nurtured for a century.
What is the nature of the complaint against Rev. Tuggle? (Added 9.4.26)
In the formal complaint filed by the district superintendent against Rev. Tuggle on July 21, 2026, Rev. Tuggle is accused of disobedience to the United Methodist Church and undermining the ministry of the bishop by acquiescing to our Church's current governance structure.
Rev. Tuggle does not have the authority to revise the Church’s bylaws. That authority belongs to the Church Council, as it has for the past 27 years.
In 1998, HPUMC’s Charge Conference, in partnership with the conference and bishop at the time, unanimously delegated authority to enact and amend the Church’s bylaws to the Church Council, and bylaws adopted in 1999 and amended from time to time thereafter reflected that governance structure. This model has enabled our congregation to be governed and led effectively while maintaining its ministry and ecclesiastical beliefs.
Accordingly, Rev. Tuggle cannot reasonably be held accountable or subjected to disciplinary action for failing to take an action that was not within his authority or responsibility. The decision to amend the bylaws rests with the Church Council, not the senior pastor, under the very rules the conference approved 27 years ago.
The complaint process is ongoing, and the next step would be a dismissal of the complaint, pursue a just resolution, or refer the matter to the Committee on Investigation.
Does the bishop have the authority to remove or reappoint our clergy? (Added 9.4.26)
In general, UMC bishops have significant ecclesiastical authority over clergy, including appointing and reappointing pastors, and moving clergy or changing clergy appointments at any time.
We are committed to taking care of our clergy, including in the face of any threats made to their pensions or health plans.
What are our options to resolve this dispute outside of court? (Updated 9.21.26)
While we have hoped and prayed that the bishop and the conference would honor the authority of our Church Council as the governing body of our Church as it has for the past 27 years, that has not been the outcome.
On September 21, 2026, we filed an “Original Answer, Affirmative Defenses, Rule 91a Motion and Plea to the Jurisdiction, and Counterclaim” in response to the lawsuit filed by the conference.
In doing so, we set the record straight, correcting the false claims made by the conference in its lawsuit, which include:
Falsely stating that we did not inform the conference about the corporate documents that were amended in 2022.
Falsely claiming that the corporate amendments effectively represented a silent disaffiliation with the conference and the United Methodist Church.
Falsely claiming that the conference did everything possible to avoid filing a lawsuit against our Church, and that it did so as a last resort.
All of these claims are blatantly untrue and merit correction on public record. Additionally, we are asking the court to dismiss the claims made by the conference in their entirety, enter a judgment in favor of HPUMC, and award the Church its legal fees for responding to this unnecessary and legally unsupported lawsuit.
Who is responsible for the governance and business of HPUMC? (Added 10.12.26)
The Church Council is the governing board of the Church. The Church Council oversees the Church’s business and affairs and has authority to make decisions on behalf of the Church within the boundaries of the Church’s governing documents.
The Church Council includes both designated leaders—such as the Church Council Chair, Senior Minister, and chairs of key committees—and elected at-large members. The Council meets regularly, makes decisions by majority vote when a quorum is present, and requires a two-thirds vote for certain significant matters.
How are Church Council members selected? (Added 10.12.26)
The Church Council is made up of both designated members and at-large members. Designated members serve on the Council because they hold certain elected church leadership positions. At-large members are nominated by the Nominations Committee and elected by the Church Council at its annual meeting. At-large members serve staggered three-year terms.
The Church Council approves its members each year at a Charge Conference, a formal church meeting. The District Superintendent facilitates the meeting, but only the church members may vote. Any HPUMC member may attend the Charge Conference, which is held annually in December. The Church Council has been approved through this process every year since 1998, including most recently in December 2025.
In other words, the Church Council does not choose or appoint its own members. The Church Council approves its membership each year through an established church process open to HPUMC members.
How can congregants suggest someone for Church Council? (Added 10.12.26)
The Nominations Committee identifies, encourages, and evaluates potential lay leaders and nominates candidates for all the church’s lay-led committees identified in our Bylaws, including the Church Council, each year. Congregants and staff participate annually by recommending individuals they believe would be good candidates for church leadership.
How is the congregation’s voice protected? (Added 10.12.26)
HPUMC’s Church Council is the primary governing body for the church’s day-to-day administration and ministry. This means the congregation does not need to vote on every operational decision. Instead, the Church Council is entrusted with that responsibility and is made up of leaders representing different areas of the life and ministry of the church.
What does the Church Council’s decision to “take a pause” from recognizing the authority of the bishop and conference mean in practice? (Added 9.4.26)
The Aug. 20, 2026 resolution seeks to slow down the denomination’s actions. On the heels of the conference filing a written complaint against our senior minister, filing a lawsuit against our Church, launching a proactive PR campaign, and summoning our clergy to tell them their pensions and health care plans were at imminent risk—all planned quietly over months and launched together without warning—hitting “pause” felt reasonable and necessary. The resolution paused our interactions with the conference and bishop “in the interim of discussions,” not indefinitely, and “foremost” to protect against “further punitive actions against the Church or its beloved Clergy” in the interim, giving us a chance to inform our congregation on what the conference had done and thoughtfully consider our path forward.
What would leaving the United Methodist Church mean? (Added 10.12.26)
First, it is important to distinguish between Methodism and the United Methodist Church. Methodism is the broader Christian tradition our Church has been part of for 110 years. The United Methodist Church is one denomination within that tradition. In fact, United Methodists represent roughly 12% of Methodists worldwide. The Horizon Texas Conference is the regional body through which we are currently connected to the UMC.
If HPUMC were to leave the UMC, we would not be leaving Methodism or abandoning our Wesleyan roots. We would remain a Methodist church, and that commitment would continue to be reflected in our theology, our operations, and the way we worship, serve, and make disciples.
How are the Church’s apportionments to the conference currently being managed? (Added 9.4.26)
The conference accepted our apportionments without complaint as recently as this August. Now that the conference has sued us, we are paying our $125,000 monthly apportionments into an escrow account as we thoughtfully evaluate how to move forward with our Church family in light of this unjust lawsuit.
Are the congregation’s tithes to the Church being used for legal fees? (Added 9.4.26)
No. All tithes continue to support the mission of our Church. Several members of our congregation have graciously offered to cover the Church’s legal fees as related to the Horizon Texas Conference’s lawsuit.
If it’s determined by the court system that HPUMC was not in compliance with the United Methodist Church’s "Book of Discipline" is my baptism, wedding or funeral still recognized?
This dispute in no way, shape or form alters the sacraments to God that have been made in our Church.
What happens next? (Updated 10.20.26)
Right now, Church leaders are focused on understanding what is best for our church, protecting our historic ministry, and ensuring we can continue serving our congregation and community.
The lawsuit is an active legal matter, and the court will determine the next steps. At the same time, our Church Council and lay leadership will continue working to understand the implications for HPUMC and to communicate with the congregation as more information becomes available.
The question before us right now is whether HPUMC should remain in or leave the United Methodist Church, and that is a significant decision for our Church. That decision will be made by a church-wide vote of HPUMC’s members, following the Church processes in our voting details section on the website.